Article Summary
Governance in Army must do more than enforce compliance: it must create conditions for sound judgement and disciplined initiative. The author connects ethical leadership and organisational culture with mission command, arguing that excessive control can suppress information, innovation, and opportunity. Effective governance should make authority and accountability clear while enabling commanders to accept prudent risk within legal and ethical boundaries. The article invites leaders to consider whether their systems genuinely support mission outcomes.
"Never tell people how to do things. Tell them what to do, and they will surprise you with their ingenuity."
– General George S Patton
Introduction
This article argues that good governance in the Australian Army is achieved not through increased control or compliance alone, but through integrating leadership, culture, and mission command principles that enable informed risk-taking. Governance is most effective when it establishes the conditions for commanders and subordinates to exercise judgement, pursue opportunities, and accept calculated risk within clearly defined ethical, legal, and strategic boundaries.[i]
Traditional views of governance often emphasise oversight, assurance, accountability, and compliance. While these elements remain essential, they are insufficient in military organisations operating in increasingly complex, contested, and uncertain operating environments. The Australian Army's ability to generate combat power, adapt to changing circumstances, and achieve strategic objectives depends not merely on adherence to process but on leadership, the strength of organisational culture, and the effective application of mission command.
Australian Defence Force (ADF) doctrine explicitly recognises that doctrine itself requires judgement in application, reinforcing the core principle that governance must enable decision-making rather than replace it.[ii]
Governance Beyond Compliance
Governance is properly understood as the framework through which an organisation is directed, controlled, and held accountable. However, governance must not be conflated with mere administration. Effective governance creates the organisational environment in which sound decisions are made, resources are appropriately applied, and strategic objectives are achieved.
The profession of arms presents a unique governance challenge. The Australian Army must continuously reconcile the requirements of public accountability and administrative control with the operational imperative for agility, initiative, and rapid decision-making. Excessive control risks creating a culture of compliance and risk aversion. Conversely, insufficient governance can lead to inconsistency, unethical conduct, and systemic failures that threaten mission success. The enduring challenge for Australian Army leaders at all levels is therefore to establish governance systems that provide rigorous assurance without suppressing subordinate initiative.
Leadership as the Enabler of Governance
Leadership is the primary mechanism through which governance becomes an operational reality. While governance frameworks establish authority, accountability, and baseline standards, leaders bring these frameworks to life through their decisions, behaviours, and priorities. ADF doctrine identifies leadership as a foundational element of professional military effectiveness and a guide for leader development across the force.[iii] Leadership therefore serves not merely as a management function but as the link between formal governance structures and organisational behaviour.
Research on ethical leadership reinforces this proposition. Brown and Treviño demonstrate that individuals learn expected behaviours through observing what leaders reward, tolerate, and punish.[iv] Similarly, Metwally and Ruiz-Palomino highlight that ethical military leadership plays a vital role in supporting personnel during periods of uncertainty and organisational change.[v] Ethical leadership therefore provides an essential governance mechanism because it establishes the unwritten behavioural norms that dictate how authority is exercised across the hierarchy.
Culture and the Exercise of Judgement
If leadership activates governance, culture shapes how governance is experienced throughout the force. The Australian Army is inherently hierarchical, yet strategic, operational, and tactical effectiveness frequently depends upon decentralised decision-making. This friction can only be reconciled through an institutional culture anchored in trust, professionalism, and disciplined initiative.
In his Chauvel Prize-winning article, Corporal John Welfare argued that military professionalism demands an openness to new ideas, self-reflection, and continuous adaptation. Army culture must actively support critical thinking and challenge institutional assumptions to remain effective in a rapidly changing strategic environment.[vi] Military ethics scholarship underscores this requirement: Weber and Gerde found that ethical work climates strongly influence individual decision-making, showing that military personnel respond to shared perceptions of peer behaviour as much as formal orders.[vii] Governance therefore depends upon an Australian Army culture that reinforces ethical conduct and professional judgement.
A culture characterised by mutual trust encourages subordinates to exercise initiative and report emerging risks early. Conversely, cultures dominated by zero-defect mentalities, excessive hierarchy, or bureaucratic compliance discourage innovation and suppress critical information. In such environments, governance processes remain formally intact while true operational effectiveness quietly deteriorates.
Risk Acceptance and Opportunity
Perhaps the most misunderstood aspect of governance is the role of risk. Poor governance is rightly associated with unmanaged risk. However, effective governance does not seek to eliminate risk; it seeks to ensure that risk is consciously identified, assessed, and accepted where necessary to exploit opportunity and achieve the mission. Modern risk management theory recognises that risk and opportunity are intrinsically linked. ISO 31000 emphasises that risk management should be integrated into governance, strategy, culture, and decision-making because uncertainty generates threats and opportunities alike.[viii]
This principle is vital to military operations in contested environments. Operational success frequently requires commanders to exploit fleeting opportunities under conditions of extreme ambiguity. Mission command dictates that subordinate leaders must be empowered to accept prudent risk, where doing so advances the commander’s intent.
The Australian Army Standing Instruction (Military Risk Management) (MRM) defines risk as the "effect of uncertainty on objectives," encompassing both potential hazards and positive opportunities.[ix] MRM standardises risk-informed decision-making to enhance operational effectiveness and encourage innovation. The updated Australian Army Standing Instruction (Compliance and Assurance) incorporates this risk-informed decision-making approach to provide a framework through which Australian Army leaders can document their decision to deviate from administrative policy to achieve their mission.[x]
Mission Command as a Governance Philosophy
Mission command provides the operational philosophy for governance that enables rather than constrains decision-making. John Blaxland noted in the Australian Army Journal that mission command reflects a deep historical tradition of empowering subordinate leaders while maintaining alignment with commander intent.[xi]
Mission command is founded on mutual trust, shared understanding, clear intent, disciplined initiative, and risk acceptance.[xii] Rather than directing every action, commanders establish clear boundaries and outcomes, delegating authority to subordinates to exercise judgement. This represents military governance in its most effective form: clear accountability combined with empowered execution.
Major General Chris Field argued that mission command and "Good Soldiering" are mutually reinforcing concepts based upon trust, character, initiative, and teamwork. Significantly, he identifies risk acceptance as one of the core principles linking culture and mission command, demonstrating that the Army's cultural aspirations are inseparable from its command philosophy.[xiii] Addressing the state of the Australian Army profession, former Chief of Army Lieutenant General Simon Stuart similarly emphasised that professional mastery and the human dimension of combat demanded flexible command arrangements capable of preparing soldiers for combat.[xiv] Leadership, culture, and governance are therefore complementary rather than competing concepts in the Australian Army.
Conclusion
Good governance within the Australian Army cannot be achieved through control and compliance alone. It emerges from the interaction of ethical leadership, a healthy culture, mission command, and risk-informed decision-making. Governance frameworks provide the authority, accountability, and assurance necessary for the Australian Army to retain legitimacy and public trust. Leadership gives practical effect to those frameworks through example, direction, and influence. Culture determines whether governance is experienced as empowerment or bureaucratic constraint. Mission command provides the philosophy through which authority is decentralised and initiative encouraged. The deliberate acceptance of prudent risk transforms governance from a mechanism of constraint into an enabler of combat capability.
Ultimately, governance exists not to eliminate uncertainty but to create the conditions in which commanders at all levels can exercise sound judgement, exploit opportunities, and win in battle.
Still Interested?
Why not also read Connecting Good Soldiering and Mission Command
Explore Cove+ short learning courses on related professional military education topics
End Notes
[i] Australian Defence Force 2021, ADF Philosophical Doctrine – Leadership
[ii] Australian Defence Force 2024, ADF Philosophical Doctrine – Command, Australian Defence Force 2024, ADF Philosophical Doctrine – Culture in the Profession of Arms.
[iii] Australian Defence Force 2021, ADF Philosophical Doctrine - Leadership
[iv] Brown, ME & Treviño, LK 2006, ‘Ethical leadership: A review and future directions’, The Leadership Quarterly, vol. 17, no. 6, pp. 595–616.
[v] Metwally, M & Ruiz-Palomino, P 2022, ‘The organisational psychology of ethical military leadership during times of crisis: Lessons from the COVID-19 pandemic’, Journal of Military Ethics, vol. 21, no. 3–4, pp. 337–346.
[vi] Welfare, J 2025, ‘The Professional Revolution to Transform Army into an Integrated Enabler’, The Australian Army Journal, vol. 21, no. 3
[vii]. Meredith, LS, Sims, CS, Batorsky, BS, Okunogbe, AT, Bannon, BL & Myatt, CA 2017, ‘Identifying promising approaches to U.S. Army Institutional Change: A review of the literature on organisational culture and climate’, www.rand.org, 5 December, RAND.
[viii] International Organisation for Standardisation 2021, ISO 31000:2018 Risk management.
[ix] The Australian Army n.d., Army Standing Instruction (Military Risk Management), page 1.1
[x] The Australian Army, 2026, Army Standing Instruction (Compliance and Assurance)
[xi] Blaxland, J 2020, ‘Mission Command and the Australian Army (Mission Command response)’, The Australian Army Journal, vol. 21, no. 3.
[xii] Australian Defence Force 2021, ADF Philosophical Doctrine - Leadership
[xiii] Field, C 2019, ‘Connecting Good Soldiering and Mission Command’, cove.army.gov.au, 3 December 2019.
[xiv] Stuart, S 2024, The human face of battle and the state of the Army profession