Anyone who opens a book review of Meditations is expecting to learn about Stoicism. Those in the military fraternity are especially hungry for quotes to spur them on to get up at 5am, take cold plunges, and be super rational all the time. So, before you get too ravenous, you should know that this review has nothing at all to do with Stoicism. If you feel the need to feed your craving for Stoic life-lessons, feast your eyes on this, your ears on this, or tuck into a full course of this. For those of you still here, let’s put what's left of Meditations under the reading light and take a closer look.

Despite being quite busy at the time[1], Aurelius still managed to write almost 500 reflections that now comprise the twelve books of Meditations. He wrote expecting his work to be private upon his death. Little did he know that his secret notebook would become assigned reading for millions, including us, the fine soldiers of the Australian Army. As far as mandatory reading goes, we could do worse. For our new-gen screen-raised digs, be assured that Aurelius writes in fun-sized passages no more than a few paragraphs long – perfect for sneaking a bit of philosophy between brain-rot reels. You don’t even have to get off your phone if you download the Meditations app. If only that was a joke. Moving on…

Lesson 1 – Talk To Yourself

The first thing to notice is that Marcus loves a chat. He talks to himself about everything: death, duty, human nature, suffering, even how to deal with people who have bad breath[2]. He wonders about metaphysics at one moment, then at another reminds himself “not be obsessed with quail-fighting.[3]” The road out of confusion and toward creativity starts with tuning-in to your inner-voice, accepting what comes up, and connecting thoughts to notice unexpected patterns. One day Aurelius might be looking up at the sky, pondering the nature of the cosmos when he suddenly realises: it’s quails all the way down[4].

We spend most of our days in our own heads talking to ourselves. Reading Meditations is like putting a stethoscope to Aurelius’ skull and listening to his inside thoughts. We can see the way he talks to himself shapes how he feels, what he does, and what he ends up believing – for better or worse. The accidental lesson here is that tuning-in to your thoughts, cosmic or trivial, is a huge step toward understanding them. In the end, Aurelius wants to carry on his inner conversation on the outside. So he picks up a pen.

Lesson 2 – Write To Yourself

Thank Zeus the internet didn’t exist in the year 175 AD. If it did, historians all agree Aurelius would have become a self-improvement influencer on Substack with a podcast sponsored by Stoic Supps™. As mercy would have it, the only medium Marcus had to self-publish was good ol’ pen and papyrus.

We arrive at Aurelius’ second accidental lesson: write to yourself. Writing seemed especially relieving to Marcus as he dealt with other people. Around one-fifth of Meditations is dedicated to his feelings toward stupid, ungrateful, conniving, jealous, meddling, lazy, and utterly incompetent people[5]. Although none of these people exist in the Australian Army, we can still learn something from Marcus' habit of writing down his big emotions before acting on them. Writing never solves his frustration, but it seems to succeed in preventing any untimely interpersonal culminations[6].

As Roman Emperor, Aurelius had few trusted confidants with whom he could have a royal yap and spill the tea. Command was as lonely in the Roman Empire as it is in Russell Offices. As Commanding Officer of The Known World, when Aurelius falls out with a colleague, his venting choices are limited. Literally everyone alive is his subordinate. So, Aurelius opens up his ancient HR handbook and starts writing self-soothing mantras about tolerance and acceptance:

The best revenge is not to be like that.[7]
Ignoring what goes on in other people’s souls—no one ever came to grief that way.[8]
There have to be shameless people in the world. This is one of them.[9]
Leave other people’s mistakes where they lie.[10]
People exist for one another. You can instruct or endure them.[11]
So other people hurt me? That’s their problem. Their character and actions are not mine.[12]

Leaders talk about the courage to be disliked but rarely do they speak candidly on their dislike of others. Lincoln famously wrote ‘hot letters’[13] when he was enraged and then kept them unsent in a drawer. Every day, unsent letters, burn books, and deleted draft emails save relationships that would otherwise be damaged by impulsive emotion. Writing creates time for us to cool down, gives us the emotional distance to figure out what we really think, and gives the angels of our better nature a chance. After writing we can think and act more clearly. Aurelius never stops complaining about the hell that is other people. Ironically, this is exactly what helps him treat them well. Complaining is cathartic. Rage needs a place to go. Next time you meet with incompetence, pick up a pen, let it rip, then rip it up.

Lesson 3 – Question Yourself

Legend has it that the editorial team at The Cove doesn’t publish anything without at least one gratuitous senior leadership quote plus one from Clausewitz for bonus points (Cove Editor's Note: We also accept Bill Slim or Jomini, thank you very much). What luck that just last week, our own Chief of Army LTGEN Susan Coyle[14] gave praise to questions and adaptation:

“A profession that ceases to question itself risks becoming complacent; a profession that continually reflects upon its purpose remains capable of adaptation and improvement.” 

One down. Now let’s go for extra credit with Clausewitz On War:

“The influence of theoretical principles upon real life is produced more through criticism than through doctrine.”[15]

If LTGEN Coyle, Clausewitz, and Marcus Aurelius all want soldiers to get after questions, who are we to say no? What these three military minds recognise is the importance of not taking anything for granted: adapting to reality is possible only through a process of reflection driven by questions. For Coyle, questions are the antidote to a complacent profession. For Clausewitz, criticism bridges principles, doctrine, and real life. For Aurelius, questions get him out of bed:

“At dawn, when you have trouble getting out of bed, tell yourself: “I have to go to work—as a human being. What do I have to complain of, if I’m going to do what I was born for—the things I was brought into the world to do? Or is this what I was created for? To huddle under the blankets and stay warm? —But it’s nicer here.... So you were born to feel “nice”? Instead of doing things and experiencing them? Don’t you see the plants, the birds, the ants and spiders and bees going about their individual tasks, putting the world in order, as best they can? And you’re not willing to do your job as a human being? Why aren’t you running to do what your nature demands? … People who love what they do wear themselves down doing it, they even forget to wash or eat.”[16]

Before you soak up those tempting stoic lifehacks about getting up early, making your bed, and running like an animal[17], pay attention to how Aurelius arrives at his answers. In the space of one paragraph, he asks himself eight questions. What gets Aurelius out of bed is not moral willpower or caffeine but plain old questions. He starts out wanting to bed-rot and eight questions later he concludes he should not only be out of the blankets, but running out the door to do what nature demands with such focus that he forgets to shower and eat breakfast. That’s some powerful Socratic questioning.

Good questions are life changing. Psychologists know this well and use questions generously. And how do you feel about that? What was that like? Questions help us crack open our assumptions to reveal the set of beliefs beneath that may or may not be working for us. The trick is to keep going – to ask, and ask, and ask – following that downward arrow until you hit something that clarifies your whole chain of thinking and helps clear the way to change.

An Unstoic Summary

So when we strip Meditations of its famous Stoic principles, what remains are three accidentally brilliant lessons in self-reflection. These self-reflective habits grow with you, around you, and are universally applicable. Reflection can lead you to stoicism, as it did with Aurelius, or away from it. Wherever the process of self-reflection takes you, at least you know you got there yourself. It makes your fate easier to embrace: in Latin, we might even say that reflection is the path to amor fati – love of fate. That has a ring to it – maybe someone should write about it?

 For now, remember three things:

  1. Talk To Yourself: tune in to your inner dialogue
  2. Write To Yourself: use writing to express yourself
  3. Question Yourself: keep asking questions until you change

Self-reflection is no cheap Stoic trick – it’s a philosophical skill that’s good for life as a citizen, soldier, or veteran. Aurelius talked, wrote, and questioned himself all the way to stoicism. As for you, who knows where philosophy might take you?

Wait! Before You Go…
Why did I bother writing a review of Meditations that disses stoicism?

I’m so glad you asked. Even though I love Meditations, I don’t love Stoicism. There is good reason to worry about the effects of Stoicism on the emotional lives of young men – especially those becoming soldiers[18]. Yes, there are bits that are useful. But much of modern Stoicism is oversimplified, commercialised, and misunderstood. It is no longer a rigorous system of philosophical thought. It has been co-opted by influencers who sell a damaging brand of masculinity to those most in need of better emotional guidance.

I hesitated to criticise Stoicism at all. I’m sensitive to the special place it occupies in the military mindset. The last thing I want is to alienate the very people I joined to help by tripping that delicate wire that makes them dismiss what I’m saying as ‘weak’ or ‘soft’. But, as a wise man once said, the obstacle is the way. I decided humour was the best way slip under your radar and get you to a point of curiosity. A full critique of Stoicism is the topic for another day. For now, I want to seed some doubts about two major Stoic claims Aurelius makes: to make the mind a fortress and to practice indifference.

“…when it withdraws into itself and finds contentment there, the mind is invulnerable. It does nothing against its will… The mind without passions is a fortress. No place is more secure. Once we take refuge there we are safe forever…”[19]

Aurelius’ suggestion to psychologically withdraw to an “inner fortress” to become “invulnerable” may serve the soldier in a trench but it will prove disastrous for that same soldier in their relationships. After all, a fortress is a place of defence. If we are too enthusiastic in building up our inner fortress, we are likely to close up whenever we feel emotional heat at the gates. I have seen many times how this inner fortress ends up becoming a prison that locks people out of close relationships and out of their own feelings. Aurelius says nothing about how or when to leave the fortress.

To rid his mind of ‘passions’ Aurelius becomes indifferent. He tries to be neutral to experience, to pursue neither pleasure nor pain, to withhold judgement on everything good or bad. His mantra is to “be indifferent to what makes no difference.”[20] But beware: Aurelius’ practice of indifference throws the baby out with the bathwater. As much as indifference insulates against anxiety, loss, and frustration it also eliminates possibilities for joy, play, and love. He urges himself to “blot out imagination”[21], cultivate detachment from music and art[22], and contemplate the death of his own children[23] as an exercise in anticipatory grief. In finding his tranquillity, he kills his joy. For Aurelius, this might be what he needs. After all, he does think life is warfare:

“Human life. Duration: momentary. Nature: changeable. Perception: dim. Condition of Body: decaying. Soul: spinning around. Fortune: unpredictable. Lasting Fame: uncertain. Sum Up: The body and its parts are a river, the soul a dream and mist, life is warfare and a journey far from home, lasting reputation is oblivion. Then what can guide us? Only philosophy.”[24]

No one could accuse Aurelius of being too sunny. His serious pursuit of virtue casts a heavy shadow over the lighter sides of life. Don’t you wonder if we’d be better off riding out emotional turbulence as opposed to not flying at all? I think it’s far better to take the leap.

“Seriousness is not a virtue … seriousness is a vice. It is really a natural trend to take oneself gravely, because it is the easiest thing to do. It is much easier to write a good leading article than a good joke. For solemnity flows out of men naturally; but laughter is a leap. 
It is easy to be heavy: hard to be light.”[25]

Despite its limits, Meditations is still one of my favourite books. I’ve read it many times over the last 15 years. First as a true believer, then as a confused disciple, then as a doubter. Now, as a psychologist, a husband and father of two sons, I read it as a careful critic. I chose to review it because Meditations is the gateway text to modern Stoicism. I wanted to talk to you early and give you the guidance I didn’t get when I was 19. Go ahead and read Meditations. Engage with Stoicism critically. Take what you need as you need it. And please, for the love of Zeus, hold Aurelius’ methods close but his conclusions lightly. Talk to yourself, write to yourself, and question yourself. All in the pursuit of the highest aim of all philosophy: to know thyself.[26]

End Notes 

[1] While writing Meditations, Aurelius was occupied fighting barbarians on the Danube, managing a devastating plague, and raising Commodus — a parenting project that did not end well for anyone except Russell Crowe.

[2] Meditations 5.28

[3] Ibid 1.6 

[4] Philosophy pun alert: in a story attributed to Bertrand Russell, the Earth rests on a giant turtle. When asked what is under that turtle, he says it is supported by another turtle, and so on: “turtles all the way down.” A joke about infinite regress. 

[5] Meditations 2.1

[6] Unfortunately, Alternate Dispute Resolution didn’t exist in Ancient Rome

[7] Meditations 6.6

[8] Ibid. 2.8 

[9] Ibid. 9.42

[10] Ibid. 9.20 

[11] Ibid. 8.59 

[12] Ibid. 5.25

[13] Abraham Lincoln, unsent letter to Major General George G. Meade, 14 July 1863

[14] LTGEN Susan Coyle, Foreword to Jordan Beavis, The Australian Army Profession: Theories, Concepts, and Principles (Australian Army Research Centre, 2026)

[15] Carl von Clausewitz, On War, Book II, Chapter V, “Criticism,” translated by J. J. Graham

[16] Meditations 5.1

[17] For more, see Jocko Willink, Discipline Equals Freedom (2017); William H. McRaven, Make Your Bed (2017); and David Goggins, Can't Hurt Me (2018).

[18] See Seidler et al. (2016) on Stoicism and masculine norms as barriers to psychological help-seeking; McAllister et al. (2019) on emotional expression and military masculinity; and the Royal Commission into Defence and Veteran Suicide (2024, Chapter 15) on military cultures of Stoicism and barriers to care. 

[19] Meditations 8.48

[20] Ibid. 11.16

[21] Ibid. 9.7

[22] Ibid. 11.2

[23] Ibid. 11.34

[24] Ibid. 2.17 

[25] G. K. Chesterton, Orthodoxy (1908), Chapter VII, “The Eternal Revolution.” 

[26] See Plato, Protagoras, 343b.

Reaction
000